The truth about IDEA – Who is Deborah Blair Porter?
There is a shocking mole in the world of journalism.
Deborah Blair Porter appears to have an impressive resume, writing for Edweek, The Los Angeles Times and The Daily Breeze. She might have even had a local council position in the South Bay of Los Angeles at some point. Ms. Porter has a “secret” that creates a journalistic bias in the most egregious way. Keep reading for more.
Ms. Porter clearly supports the Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA), this is not unusual. I have never heard of anyone who has ever been against it. I recently read an article authored by Ms. Porter that was published in Edweek. The content and comments in her article were disingenuous and embarrassing at least. Many sarcastic comments precede her accusation of letter writing campaigns en masse by the PTA to their legislatures to oppose IDEA. She claims that the PTAs are, “blaming special education students and their parents” for the budget crisis in California.
Before I comment on the balance of Ms. Porter’s article, I will address her letter writing campaign statement. I searched the California PTA’s website where I reviewed all information about special education. I found nothing about letter writing campaigns for special education. What I did find was an informational packet instructing parents how to identify learning disabilities to discover if they’re student is eligible for IDEA benefits. There are two bills that the PTA supports regarding IDEA, AB661 Toralkson and AB826 Buchanan. These bills attempt to apportion more state money to IDEA.
Apart from the state PTA, I did find a proposed letter writing campaign from Mission Viejo asking its membership to bring to the attention of the legislature that their school district had spent an additional $13.7 in mandated IDEA services. The letter to the membership was authored by Caroline Paltin, Ph.D., Special Education Chair for the Special Education Committee. Hardly an attack on IDEA; Special Education Chair, Dr. Paltin, clearly is trying to mitigate the damage of financial requirements by asking the federal government to properly fund the IDEA programs, instead of having the funding come from the local school districts. http://www.svpta.org/newsletters/march08.pdf
Another local PTA, in a school district in Santa Barbara, stated that the PTA strongly supports increasing federal funding for IDEA. I am not sure how that is a letter writing campaign, but perhaps it should be.
Is it possible that Ms. Porter does not understand that a PTA asking for federal funding for IDEA services does not equate to “blaming special education students and their parents”?
She goes on to negatively point out that some people “believe the responsibility for educating [special education] lies elsewhere.” That statement is accurate, but I am not sure why she puts a negative spin on it, well – maybe I know why. More on that later. The reason why people believe that the responsibility lies elsewhere is because … the responsibility lies elsewhere in the case of IDEA. IDEA, a federal act has defined and imposed services and mandates on the states for special education.
IDEA again are mandates and not suggestions. However, the federal government only funds about 19% of the cost of IDEA services and other costs, the state (SELPA) kicks in another 28% leaving school districts to use its own unrestricted funds to cover the balance of the costs, this fund is called an encroachment fund.
The aforementioned school district in Mission Viejo had an encroachment fund for IDEA in the sum of $13.7 million, and that’s about average. That encroachment fund comes straight from school districts’ budgets and from other school education programs, library and PE, including the lay off of teachers which will cause larger class sizes in 2009-10. I am not sure why Ms. Porter assesses any of the PTA positions as, “a new level of blame [sec] being directed squarely at parents of kids with special needs.”
Ms. Porter further attempts to make the claim that: “According to the U.S. Department of [sec] Education is primarily a State and local responsibility in the United States.”
Good grief. This was her best analysis of why the states should be paying the bill for IDEA? First of all, the parents who are concerned about the funding are not mad at the state for not funding the program, it’s about the inequity of the school districts having to pay over 50% of the services from their own local budgets. In any event, her explanation about states and education is unimpressive and unreliable in her context. States having responsibility to educate its students is attributed to the 10th Amendment of the Constitution (Bill of Rights) establishing that because education is not mentioned in the Constitution, therefore the responsibility belongs to the states to decide education priorities.
Although she failed to properly analyze the states’ rights on education, or she willfully slanted the truth, she provided the perfect example to illustrate why the federal government should not be making mandates and acts that require outside funding from states and school districts. As prescribed by a case in 1992, the Supreme Court made a ruling on a case alleging a violation of the 10th Amendment, New York v. The United States of America (1992), 505 U.S. 14. The Supreme Court, in a 6–3 decision, found that federally mandated programs violated the states rights under the 10th Amendment. In her decision, Justice Sandra Day O’Connor found that the federal government can encourage but cannot mandate conditions for a federal Act and that the federal government cannot directly compel states to enforce federal regulations by forcing the funding.
The federal government has no business mandating federal acts on the states. That’s the point. Yes, the states need to balance their own budgets and make cuts according to their revenues. Yet the federal government mandates IDEA programs without consideration of the hardship that the mandates cause and the required cuts elsewhere. The state should be able to educate all of the students including those with disabilities.
Ms. Porter is correct that it’s the state’s right, but then why defend IDEA mandates handed down from the federal government? You cannot have it both ways, Ms. Porter. Ms. Porter woefully failed to appropriately analyse any of her legal findings. This is odd for a reporter to do. Why did she do this?
It becomes apparent when you find that Ms. Porter sued the Manhattan Beach Unified School District for IDEA inadequacies and found herself a millionaire with a nearly $8 million settlement that came directly from the Manhattan Beach school district budget. The case is entitled, Porter v. Board of Trustees, Manhattan Beach Unified School District 307 F3d. 1064. Indeed, incorporated in the IDEA statutes, there is an affirmative proviso for assumed conflicts followed by legal entitlements for those who are not satisfied with the school’s adherence. Ms. Porter, in her lawsuit, claimed time and again that the special education services for her son were not provided to her satisfaction. Though her child has delayed learning and a mild spectrum of autism, she insisted on a one-on-one aid and other benefits for which her child was not qualified to receive. According to the Manhattan Beach special education department, the school district offered other remedies as prescribed for his condition, however, Manhattan Beach was unable to satisfy Ms. Porter’s demands for additional IEPs, programs and services. I guess she received a settlement because she exhausted everyone, driving up legal fees for the district – when she should have been exhausting her other remedies, in my opinion.
In an article that I wrote back on May 13, I unwittingly profiled the case of Porter, having had no inkling of who Porter was, I wrote: “Case in point, Porter v. Board of Trustees of Manhattan Beach Unified School District et al., 307 F. 3d 1064 (9th Cir. 2002), 537 U.S. 1194, 123 S. Ct. 1303, 154 L. Ed. 2nd 1029 (2003). In the case of Porter, the parents of a student, who had been diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder, charged that Manhattan Beach Unified School District failed to provide their child with a “free appropriate public education.” This lawsuit resulted in the school district paying over $6.7M to the family of the student. In addition, as part of the settlement, control of the student’s education was transferred to a Special Master, Ivor Weiner, Ph.D., resulting in the cost of just under $1.1M to pay for the education of the student at the direction of the Special Master.”
After I published this article, I began receiving sarcastic and nasty comments from someone defending the Porter v. Manhattan Beach case, 70 comments in 10 days. I am informed and believe that these comments came from Ms. Porter who was anonymously trying to discredit me on my own site and other sites.
Ms. Porter even embarrassingly uses her own case in her Ednews article to attempt to make a point about IDEA and defend this litigation, yet never tells her readers that she is the plaintiff in the case. I really don’t know what to say beyond that because it’s such a blow to the world of journalism and the sanctity of the truth. Why she keeps this a “secret” is beyond the stretch of my imagination. I think Edweek should give me a shot at her job, at least I would do it with honor, dignity and accuracy.
http://ednews.org/articles/whats-the-big-idea.html
About the Author
How to Use The Cir Cut I and II
|
|
FABULOUS SNOW WHITE LINEN TABLECLOTH WITH DAFFODIL CUT WORK EMBROIDERY, CIR1920 $15.00 |
|
|
Form-A-Grip Custom Archery Bow Grip Molding Kit Cir Cut $14.99 |
|
|
5 FEET CAMO CIR-CUT RELEASE NOCK D LOOP Archery Bow $4.99 |
|
|
5′ CIR-CUT CAMO RELEASE STRING D SUPER LOOP Archery Bow $4.99 |
|
|
5 Color Pack ARCHERY D NOCKING NOCK LOOP By Cir-Cut NEW $6.95 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Super-Loop String Release Loop Rope 3Pc. $2.99 |
|
|
ANTIQUE BACCARAT CUT GLASS WHISKEY DECANTER MATCHING STOPPER CIR. 1910 1920 $185.00 |
|
|
5′ STRING D NOCK LOOP NEON GREEN Cir-Cut Archery 2.4mm $4.99 |
|
|
5′ ARCHERY BOW STRING D NOCK LOOP NEON ORANGE Cir-Cut $4.99 |
|
|
BLACK CIR-CUT RELEASE NOCK D LOOP Archery Bow 3 PC PACK $3.99 |
|
|
Cir-Cut GLOW IN THE DARK Bow Sight TAPE Archery 2 PCS $2.99 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Camo Fleece Super Quiet Bow Silencing Tape $10.28 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Archery Sight & Quiver Thread Repair Tap Tool $7.88 |
|
|
Form-A-Grip Custom Archery Bow Grip Molding Kit Cir Cut $18.95 |
|
|
250′ CAMO RELEASE NOCK D String LOOP Cir-Cut Archery $67.98 |
|
|
CIR CUT BRAND BLACK SUPER RELEASE NOCK D LOOP 1 FOOT $1.69 |
|
|
Extreme CROSSBOW BOW STRING & DECK WAX Archery CIR-CUT $3.99 |
|
|
Archery VIPER D RELEASE LOOP PLIERS + 5′ CIR-CUT GREEN $23.99 |
|
|
Archery VIPER D RELEASE LOOP PLIERS + 5′ CIR-CUT CAMO $23.99 |
|
|
Archery VIPER D RELEASE LOOP PLIERS + 5′ CIR-CUT PINK $23.99 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Aluminum Washers, 12 Pk. $4.75 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Rubber O-Ring Washers, 12 Pk. $4.75 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Steel Rhino Washers, 12 Pk. $4.75 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Reflective Arrow Locator Tape $1.99 |
|
|
ANTLER SCULPT REPAIR KIT by Cir-Cut THE ORIGINAL BONE $21.95 |
|
|
CIR-CUT BRAND 2.4MM SUPER D LOOP CAMO 5 FOOT LENGTH $7.00 |
|
|
5 Color SET ARCHERY RELEASE ROPE 2.4mm CIR-CUT D LOOP $29.95 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Green String Whiskers Bow String Silencers $4.65 |
|
|
* REPLACEMENT BLADE* For Cir-Cut FLETCHING STRIPPER $4.99 |
|
|
REPLACEMENT BLADE * Cir Cut Archery FLETCHING STRIPPER $4.99 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Archery Felt Super Quiet Bow Silencing Material $3.88 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Whisker Bow String Silencers, Green, 100pc $23.00 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Insert Repair Tool. $11.99 |
|
|
250′ CAMO RELEASE NOCK D String LOOP Cir-Cut Archery $65.99 |
|
|
5′ Cir-Cut String Release D-Loop Flourescent Yellow $5.00 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Corporation Tornado Pro Serving Tool (CCSVOO) #1354Y $8.90 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Corporation Tornado Pro Serving Tool (CCSVOO) #1356Y $8.90 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Corporation Tornado Pro Serving Tool (CCSVOO) #1355Y $8.90 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Corporation Tornado Pro Serving Tool (CCSVOO) #1357Y $8.90 |
|
|
Cir-Cut String Pierce Tool (CCTL77) #1359Y $7.50 |
|
|
Cir-Cut String Pierce Tool (CCTL77) #1361Y $7.50 |
|
|
Cir-Cut String Pierce Tool (CCTL77) #1360Y $7.50 |
|
|
Cir-Cut String Pierce Tool (CCTL77) #1362Y $7.50 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Shaft Deburr Tool (CCTL50) #1363Y $9.90 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Shaft Deburr Tool (CCTL50) #1364Y $9.90 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Shaft Deburr Tool (CCTL50) #1365Y $9.90 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Shaft Deburr Tool (CCTL50) #1367Y $9.90 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Shaft Deburr Tool (CCTL50) #1366Y $9.90 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Fletching Stripper (CCTL90) #1369Y $9.90 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Fletching Stripper (CCTL90) #1370Y $9.90 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Arrow Point, Insert Repair Tool (CC1638) #1371Y $10.90 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Arrow Point, Insert Repair Tool (CC1638) #1372Y $10.90 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Arrow Point, Insert Repair Tool (CC1638) #1373Y $10.90 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Arrow Point, Insert Repair Tool (CC1638) #1375Y $10.90 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Arrow Point, Insert Repair Tool (CC1638) #1374Y $10.90 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Arrow Point, Insert Repair Tool (CC1638) #1376Y $10.90 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Arrow Point, Insert Repair Tool (CC1638) #1377Y $10.90 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Arrow Point, Insert Repair Tool (CC1638) #1378Y $10.90 |
|
|
20′ SPOOL Cir-Cut ARCHERY SUPER RELEASE D LOOP NOCKING $14.89 |
|
|
THERMAL DYNAMICS 7-8910 CIR/S LINE CUT GUIDE KIT 7-8910 $267.87 |
|
|
250 Cir-Cut Archery Premium ELIMINATOR E BUTTONS Release Bow String SOFT DURABLE $49.99 |
|
|
6 PACKS of CIR-CUT ARCHERY SUPER PAD – BLACK – SILENCING RESTS EQUIPMENT – QUITE $15.00 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Fletching Stripper $8.99 |
|
|
3 PC CIR-CUT RELEASE NOCK NOCKING D LOOP Archery Bow $3.99 |
|
|
Cir-Cut Archery Adhesive Felt Pads #SA-10 3-5/8″ X 10″ $4.99 |
|
|
5′ – PINK CAMO – SUPER RELEASE NOCK D LOOP Archery Bow CIR-CUT BRAND STIFF ! $4.99 |
|
|
1 pc. – PINK CAMO – ARCHERY BOW STRING RELEASE D NOCK LOOP CIR CUT BRAND NEW $1.00 |
|
|
100′ PINK CAMO Cir-Cut Archery Brand SUPER RELEASE NOCK D String LOOP THE BEST ! $35.99 |
|
|
25 FT PINK CAMO RELEASE STRING NOCKING D LOOP Archery Bow By Cir-Cut Products $13.99 |
|
|
5 FEET Cir-Cut Archery PRO GOLD – SUPER STIFF RELEASE NOCK D LOOP Bow NEW .093 $4.99 |
|
|
12′ SPOOL – PRO GOLD – CIR-CUT ARCHERY STRING RELEASE NOCK LOOP 2.4mm .093″ $9.99 |
|
|
CIR CUT BRAND – PRO GOLD – PREMIUM QUALITY SUPER RELEASE NOCK D LOOP 1 FOOT $1.69 |
|
|
CIR CUT BRAND – PINK CAMO – PREMIUM QUALITY SUPER RELEASE NOCK D LOOP 1 FOOT NEW $1.69 |
|
|
250′ PINK CAMO RELEASE NOCK D String Bowstring LOOP CORD By Cir-Cut Archery NEW $65.99 |
|
|
CIR CUT ARCHERY STRING PIERCE SERARATOR TOOL – PEEPS SERVINGS – SPREADS STRING $5.99 |
|
|
Popular Cir-Cut Corporation 15 Hot Melt Shop Stick High Quality Modern Design $7.99 … |
|
|
Popular Cir-Cut Corporation Circut Point Locks High Quality Modern Design $1.99 … |
|
|
Popular Cir-Cut Corporation Super Grip Hot Melt Adhesive 3-3/4 High Quality Modern Design $3.59 … |
|
|
Makita 5007MG Magnesium 7-1/4-Inch Circular Saw $129.00 The magnesium components create a lightweight saw that is well balanced and jobsite tough. Its powerful 15A motor delivers enough power to cut through the densest lumber. It has large cutting and bevel capacities with positive stops at 22.5 and 45, a built-in LED light and dust blower that enhance the line of cut for increase accuracy, easy-to-read numbers and ruler markings on base and depth guid… |
|
|
All-Fix 2 Part Epoxy Putty 3/4 Lb. Kit All Purpose 1001 Uses $19.95 All-Fix Epoxy Putty 12 oz. Kit (3/4 LB) … the two part amazing all purpose epoxy putty repair material. Your imagination is the only limit when it comes to the number of uses for All-Fix. This wonder material will patch holes, chips, cracks, seals & plugs leaks even underwater ! All-Fix works wonders rebuilding, fixing, restoring, bonding or creating just about anything. It can be shaped by hand… |
|
|
Hitachi C7SB2 15 Amp 7-1/4-Inch Circular Saw $83.00 This new circular saw combines Hitachi’s rock-solid construction with a lightweight and ergonomic design. The saw has a powerful and smooth-running 15 amp motor with a replaceable carbon brush for long life and easy maintenance. The saw’s aluminum-alloy base bevels from 0 to 55 degrees, with positive stops at 0 and 45 degrees. Depth of cut and bevel adjustments are both tool-free operations. The h… |
|
|
Nikon 77mm Circular Polarizer II Filter $141.95 In general, light reflected from water, glass, or other shiny materials is polarized and adversely affects image definition. Circular polarizing filters reduce or eliminate unwanted reflections and increase the overall contrast of subjects in low-contrast situations Usually, light from the sky is polarized due to reflections and dispersions in the air. Circular polarizing filters cut these reflec… |
|
|
Black Polka Circle Silver Vine Tree Rubberized Snap on Hard Plastic Cover Faceplate Case for Verizon LG Octane VN530 + Screen Protector Film $6.50 Protect and personalize your Verizon LG Octane VN530 with this Combo Protections of LCD Screen Protector Film and Snap on Hard Cover Protector Case. With this combo protections, you can protect your phone from scratches, dent, and chips. The front and back cover case is perfectly molded to fit your phone so that it won’t adding much bulk to your phone. The phone case is made of durable polycabonat… |
|
|
Blackberry 8520 Bubble Diamante Protector Cover $3.63 Protect and personalize your BlackBerry Curve 8520 / 8530 /3G 9300 /3G 9330 with this full diamond graphic case. Sparkling diamonds embedded in this case makes your BlackBerry Curve 8520 / 8530 /3G 9300 /3G 9330 more luxurious and glamorous looking. Besides, this accessory can provide protection by preventing scratches and chips. Its perfect fit does not add too much additional bulk to the BlackBe… |
|
|
Cir-Cut Camo Rope Bulk 500` $28.99 Cir-cut Camo Rope 500 feet of all-purpose camo utility cord, great for treestand pull-up ropes, decoy lines and general outdoor hunting use. 1/4 diameter, hollow flexible braid with a poly inner core. USA MFG…. |
|
|
Pearson’s Canal Companion, Stourport Ring: Black Country Canals & Birmingham Canal Navigations $8.56 New – “The Canal Companions” have been chugging along the ‘cut’ for thirty years; conveying facts and figures, insights and entertainment, wit and wisdom: from Brentford to Burscough, from Shardlow to Sharpness, from Tipton to Todmorden. All manner of folk have been encouraged to explore the inland waterways using these guides, which have become as much a part of tradition as their subject matter. This Companion is the 8th Edition of the popular Stourport Ring and Black Country Ring cruising cir |